The Berlin Secession/degenerate art: Karl Hofer
Two Girls (Zwei Mädchen), 1935
Oil on canvas
100 × 65 cm
©Kunsthalle Mannheim, Germany
Karl Hofer emerges in the 1930s as one of the most quietly resonant voices in German modernism, a painter who avoided both the shrillness of propaganda and the extremes of the avant‑garde. Two Girls belongs to the fully formed phase of his mature style, where clarity, restraint, and emotional depth converge into a language that feels timeless rather than tied to any single movement. The two girls stand pressed close together, their bodies overlapping in a way that suggests both support and vulnerability. The darker‑toned figure behind places an arm around the other’s shoulders in a gesture that is protective, possessive, or consoling—its meaning deliberately left unresolved. A subtle contrast in their skin tones reinforces the emotional asymmetry between them, the front figure appearing more exposed while the rear figure seems to anchor and envelop her. The front figure’s downcast eyes and slightly tilted posture deepen the sense of emotional weight, and the striped headscarf in muted greens and yellows lends the scene a touch of everyday intimacy, grounding this moment of closeness in a recognisable, lived world. This is not a statue‑like stillness but a quiet, inward moment of dependence and shared gravity.
Although Hofer never aligned himself with Die Brücke or Der Blaue Reiter, he absorbed their lessons—colour as emotional force, the figure as vessel of inner life—and tempered them with a classical sense of order. His response to Die Brücke was selective: he shared their psychological intensity but rejected their jagged distortion, preferring a more measured, humanistic expression. With Der Blaue Reiter, he shared an interest in the figure as a bearer of spiritual or metaphysical states, though he never followed their path toward abstraction. Where both groups eventually moved away from the figure—toward dissolution or non‑objectivity—Hofer held fast to it, refining a language of poised, monumental human presence. This quiet insistence on the dignity of the human form places him in a loose but meaningful dialogue with the Expressionist generation, even as he pursued a calmer, more classical path.
His affinity with the New Objectivity painters is visible in the controlled composition and the architectural balance of the two figures. Yet the painting’s muted, earthy palette and the rough, almost abstract background push the figures forward, intensifying their isolation and heightening the psychological charge. It is no coincidence that several of Hofer’s works appeared in the 1925 Neue Sachlichkeit exhibition at Kunsthalle Mannheim, where his poised, introspective modernism found an early institutional anchor.
By 1935, when Two Girls was painted, Hofer had reached the height of his artistic authority. Yet this moment of accomplishment unfolded under the shadow of political catastrophe. In June 1933 he was suspended from his university post; four years later, more than 300 of his works were seized from German museums and labelled “degenerate art,” (Entartete Kunst) with nine displayed in the notorious Munich exhibition. The devastation continued: in 1943, an air raid destroyed his Berlin studio along with most of the paintings stored there, erasing decades of work in a single night. Against this backdrop, the painting’s introspective, shadowed atmosphere feels deeply connected to the uncertainty of the mid‑1930s. Its quiet dignity becomes a form of resistance—a refusal to relinquish the inner life of the human figure at a time when that very humanity was under assault.

Leave a Reply